Safe? checks: is it safe to delete?

Ask Crumb whether a folder or file is safe to delete, learn what each answer means, and see what Crumb never deletes.

On this page
  1. What the answers mean
  2. What the check sends
  3. What Crumb never deletes

Found a big folder and not sure what it is? Crumb can tell you what it is and whether you can delete it. The check is in three places:

  • Check a folder on Overview: pick any folder on your Mac.
  • The Safe? button on each row in Visualize.
  • The Safe? button on each copy in Duplicates.
Check a folder on Overview: the answer for a .cache folder says Rebuilds itself, nothing lasting, regenerated automatically, with a link to Free Space
The answer opens next to the button you clicked.

What the answers mean

AnswerWhat it means
Rebuilds itselfSafe to delete. The app or tool that made it makes it again when it needs it.
Partly safeSome of it rebuilds itself, and some of it is settings or data you'd want to keep.
Your callIt's yours, and it won't come back once deleted. Look inside before you decide.
ProtectedYour own data or something macOS needs. Crumb never deletes it.

Each answer gives one plain sentence about what the item is or what would break, and says who checked it. Checked by Crumb's rules on this Mac means Crumb recognised it. When Crumb's rules don't know an item, the answer says so and asks you to check before you delete.

Most answers also link to the screen that can act on them. For something that rebuilds itself, that's Open Free Space, which removes only the parts that come back. For an app, it's Open Uninstall.

To close an answer, press Esc, click somewhere else, or click the button again.

What the check sends

The first time you use it, Crumb asks first: "To check, Crumb may send this item's name, size, type and dates. Never its contents." Click Check it to go ahead. Crumb doesn't ask again after that. The privacy policy has the details.

What Crumb never deletes

Some places are protected everywhere in Crumb. Free Space, Visualize, Uninstall, Duplicates and the weekly clean all refuse to delete them, even if you ask.

  • Your home folder, Library folder and Applications folder
  • Your Desktop, Documents, Downloads, Pictures, Movies and Music folders themselves (what's inside them is judged item by item)
  • The folders where apps keep their data and settings: Application Support, Containers, Group Containers and Preferences
  • Mail, Messages, Notes, Calendars and Contacts
  • Photos libraries and your Music library
  • iCloud Drive and files from cloud storage apps
  • Saved passwords and internet accounts
  • Safari bookmarks and history
  • SSH and GPG keys

There are two narrow exceptions. Free Space can list old iPhone and iPad backups, and files Mail has downloaded, under Your call. They're never ticked for you, so they only go if you tick them yourself.

Still stuck? Email help@cleanwithcrumb.com and tell us what you see. A screenshot helps. Or browse all the guides.